9 Comments
Mar 10, 2023Liked by Ahmed Shaikh

Great work Ahmed, keep it up inshaAllah. JazakAllah khair

Expand full comment
Mar 3, 2023Liked by Ahmed Shaikh

This erodes the public trust. Its extremely concerning that when caught in their lie, they double down and say "well there is still mental health problems." No one is denying there are issues of mental health. The problem is that you lied and doctored your studies like the many corrupt companies before you.

Expand full comment

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Expand full comment

It’s amazing how every sentence in your article is tinged with a very clear hatred. You may bring up a few good points, but the stunning paucity at the very basics of adab and naseeha immediately dilute the effectiveness of your purported findings.

Expand full comment

This erodes the public trust. Its extremely concerning that when caught in their lie, they double down and say "well there is still mental health problems." No one is denying there are issues of mental health. The problem is that you lied and doctored your studies like the many corrupt companies before you.

Expand full comment

Thank you for this.

I must admit I am a bit confused by the table below, and the authors' varying descriptions:

Muslim vs. Protestant 1.604 (0.913-2.820) 0.050

Muslim vs. Catholic 1.330 (0.743 -2.378) 0.168

Muslim vs. Jewish 2.261 (1.271 -4.019) 0.003

Muslim vs. No Religion 1.028 (0.563 -1.878) 0.464

In their direct response to Dr. Umarji on the JAMA website: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapsychiatry/fullarticle/2782161, the authors say: "Without adjusting for any variables we found that U.S. Muslims tended to be more likely to report lifetime suicide attempts compared to other faith groups" (and then present the data).

Note, they clearly say above: "Without adjusting for any variables..."

But in their private response to JAMA, they say: "During our initial analysis we calculated the odds ratios for suicide comparing each religious group to Muslims, and since there was a trend between Muslims and Protestants and a statistically significant difference between Muslim and Jewish participants we proceeded with a multivariate analysis adjusting for common risk and protective factors described in the literature:" and then present the same table.

Note, here they say they are "adjusting for common risk and protective factors..."

So, which is it? Are the data adjusted or aren't they?

Expand full comment